MySitti
FOOD & DRINKChicago

The Deep-Dish Debate: 5 Pizzas Worth the Wait

MSMySitti Editorial
Aug 2, 2026 · 5 min read

Ask five Chicagoans where to get deep-dish and you'll get six answers. We took a different route: the ratings. Across our curated database, pizza spots with more than a thousand reviews tell a clear story — and Gino's East, with 19,810 reviews at 4.7★, still wears the crown for first-timers.

The move most visitors miss

Order before you arrive. The classic rooms bake to order and a deep-dish takes 45 minutes — call ahead or order at the door and take a walk along the river while it bakes. Your future self will thank you.

Sitti's take

Visiting soon? I can build your days around everything in this story — just tell me your dates and style, and I'll do the rest.

Ready to see it yourself?

Tell Sitti your dates and style — get a day-by-day plan built from the same data behind this story.

Plan My Vacation